Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

But she said that since legalization would make an huge impact in the life of immigrants that it outweighs the 100+ billion dollars. With that logic, even one person being legalized would outweigh any budgetary impact. She's not budging, she probably got the direction from her political masters.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

The way people in this forum think about non-DACAers is the same way republicans thing about all immigrants.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

The parliamentarian seemed very focused on the essential worker provision:

I'd say removing the essential worker provision and just focusing on the DACA could probably pass the Byrd Rule? I think you can justify converting an EAD to a LPR.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

Trying to push immigration into a reconciliation bill was a political move by Dems. Parliamentarian has questioned the entire concept of legalizing the undocumented, and not just the numbers/approach, etc.

I can't think of any way around this within reconciliation, unfortunately, as long as the outcome of the policy change is giving green cards. [The whole registry date approach is nonsensical]. Reconciliation is not the vehicle for it.

My position on immigration reform is work on targeted bills, not a ginormous immigration reform. Start with the low hanging fruit of active DACA recipients, etc. (I am selfish :)) .

Democrats should have focused on smaller "wins" every year, let's say. But they chose political noise over practicality.

Now Democrats will go into midterms saying "we tried but the parliamentarian let us down." At which point, the voters will ask "who the hell is the parliamentarian", and they will vote them out!

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

If it was that simple, it would have been done. Good luck finding enough votes in the Senate.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

Exactly.

EW clause is what makes it so onerous.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

If latest news is to be followed, next "proposal" is Dreamers only immigration. If by Dreamers they strictly mean active and eligible DACA recipient, then the keys points are:

1. All DACA recipients either have an EAD or can get one. From EAD to LPR is not as big of a change as going from nothing to LPR. [Is this too big of a policy change???]

2. Giving DACA recipients permanent residency, will it have a big enough budgetary impact????

None of this looks promising.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

She pretty much signaled that she's a no regardless of the argument.

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s
 

Parliamentarian: "It's gonna be a no for me dawg"

Re: Senate Democrats have prepared an alternative proposal for the Parliamentarian’s