I know, right?! I was gonna say something to him about being "ungodly" for a pastor, but I didn't want to make things worse than they already were.

Anyway, I decided to just let it go since aside from the threat nothing else happened until I walked away. He's not making profits out of the food so I guess that unless I personally know someone getting poisoned by them I wouldn't have a good case. The guy is just a nut-job, so if he happens to be around me and threatens me again in the future, then I'll look into reporting him anonymously.

Thanks guys for the reply.