OP. Read this post carefully. First of all, YOU MUST submit Form 1-765WS. Write everything truthfully. In the paragraph, it is good if you explain your expenses (food, shelter, transportation, education tuition etc). Let's take a look at all your exhibits how I see it:

Exhibit 1 - Good
Exhibit 2 - STAMPED I-94, Immunization records, Simple copy of school registration years are sufficient. If you want include the stamped copy of the Visa page on your old passport.
Exhibit 3 - Make sure you include the ENTIRE bank statement for that billing period.
Exhibit 4 - High School Diploma only is sufficient. Get rid of everything else.
Exhibit 5 - Put high school transcripts (2006-2010) right here.Do you have anything to prove your presence between your high school graduation date 5/10/2010 and 8/8/2011? Find something for this time period because your bank statements are between 8/8/2011 - 8/8/2012. Get rid of everything else.

Your I-94 should have a stamp. That is your arrival date. If you did not leave between June 15th, 2007 up till now, don't worry about a thing. Just provide sufficient evidence to prove EXHIBIT 5. That's the biggest thing you have to prove.

The point here is you want to organize this packet so simply so the people handling your case won't be confused. Remove the redundant papers.

Regarding the dates you lived at each place, it does not have to be accurate! The application says write everything to the "best of your knowledge" Estimate the dates but FILL EVERY box. Make sure the timeline makes sense. Finally, on the applications, put the I-94 stamp date as your date of entry. Forget everything else. The I-94 will also have an abbreviation or name. That is going to be your place of entry. For example, mine had "NIA" for Niagara Falls, NY. There's a website where you can check the full name of the port of entry.

How old are you? Make sure you show your application to few other people who know what they're doing to see you put everything properly. If you want me to see it, let me know too. Just ask any questions on this thread. You'll get accurate responses. People here know what they're doing. We're getting biometrics appointments already so feel free to ask.