Cringe...
I feel you man. I really don't know what would be the correct route. I wonder, as seeing DACA is being done at a case by case basis, would they give leniency towards a case like yours.

Also what happens to a denial, would someone who has been denied without a criminal history be subjected to a appearance?

My opinion would be to hold out for CIR. The risks are too great currently.
Also have you spoke to a lawyer?