It also depends on if you were inspected on your way out of the US. Were you fingerprinted? Passport scanned? Handed in an old I-94? In other words is there a record of you leaving US after overstaying your visa?
__________________
Initial Approval: 11/13/12
1st Renewal: 10-7-14
2nd Renewal: 10/12/16
3rd Renewal: 5/16/2018