do your math and see what other benefits/ career progression you have with new job vs old. I was viewed by leadership as a top performer as well. im with with my company for 7 years and last year I applied for better job and they contacted my manager and all of sudden there was a Chao between leadership. they reached me and asked me why I decided to leave and what are my concerns. I told them that I have no problems and concerns just financial issues. they gave my 15+K as well nice career progression as well. so try to contact your leadership that you might be leaving due to financial issues and see if they can offer you more and keep in touch with other job offer as well. good luck