Key Republican in immigration debate says undocumented immigrants 'not clamoring' for

At the end of the day, I'd settle for a "legal status" for UI if dreamers are given a pathway to citizenship

CNN Senior Congressional Producer Deirdre Walsh
Washington (CNN) - Rep. Raul Labrador, a member of a bipartisan group of House members discussing immigration reform proposals, told reporters on Tuesday that he doesn't believe many of the nation’s 11.5 million undocumented immigrants want to become American citizens.

"They're not clamoring for it. It's only the activists here in Washington D.C. who keep clamoring for it," Labrador said off the House floor.
Anybody who is clamoring for citizenship - they're looking for voters and they're looking for union members. They're not looking for a political solution, they're not looking for a policy that actually strengthens the United States," Labrador said in taking a swipe at some of his GOP colleagues and others pressing proposals that create a path to citizenship.

The Idaho Republican said undocumented immigrants want legal status.

“They want to be treated with respect they want to be able to come out of the shadows and they want a program where they feel that when they are crossing the border they're not going to be detained at the border," he said.

Labrador based his assessment on his experience as an attorney in private practice before he ran for Congress.

"I've practiced immigration law for 15 years and I've dealt with thousands and thousands of people and not one of them said ‘I need a pathway to citizenship,’" Labrador said.

But the conservative lawmaker said he does support citizenship for children of those who entered the United States illegally, similar to the DREAM Act that failed to pass Congress.

"I want to treat those kids fairly who came here through no fault of their own,” he said, noting that many are in college or in the military and are doing the right things.

Asked about how the bipartisan group is grappling with the citizenship issue, Labrador declined to comment.

"I cannot talk about whether I am even part of the bipartisan group," he said.

But other sources familiar with the group confirm that Labrador has been involved in regular immigration talks with other House members.

They include: Florida Republican Mario Diaz-Balart, Texas Republicans Sam Johnson and John Carter; and Democratic Reps Rep Luis Gutierrez, Xavier Becerra, Zoe Lofgren, and John Yarmuth.

Like Labrador, other members of the group declined to talk about its internal discussions or even its existence, worried that any leaked details could jeopardize any deal.

When approached by reporters, Diaz-Balart has an answer ready for those probing for any details from the talks. "I can neither confirm nor deny that there is any group."

But Diaz-Balart does say that the political environment for a comprehensive deal is better than any other time he’s debated the issue.

Democrats in the group have all insisted for years that any immigration legislation must include a mechanism for those undocumented immigrants now in the United States to gain citizenship.

Diaz-Balart has co-sponsored a number of legislative proposals. It’s unclear whether Labrador’s position would make it impossible for him to sign on to any agreement announced by the group.

Sources familiar with the discussions tell CNN that the bipartisan group is aiming to roll out legislation, perhaps as early as after the State of the Union address next week.

Members of the House group have met weekly and some have been involved in immigration talks for year. Individual members have met with Florida Senator Marco Rubio and other members of the bipartisan Senate group that released its own immigration framework last week that did include a path to citizenship.

While some of those in the bipartisan House group believe one comprehensive bill is the only way to get both parties to pass something this year, Labrador said he believes that there will be a series of separate bills that together represent a comprehensive package.

And he argued it's more likely that the Republican-controlled House will pass legislation that limits those in the country illegally to getting legal status, not full citizenship.

"I don’t know if it's an easier sell - it's just something that comports with most of the promises that Republicans made in their campaigns," Labrador said.

is your service center texas?

Cool. My resentment toward this guy is easing up a little.

He still gets a fak u from me.....

Well most illegal immigrants who will go to a lawyer will generally ask "Is there some way for me to get a green card?", almost everyone knows that comes before one can naturalize.

That guy must have been a very bad immigration lawyer if that's his attitude.

Nebraska

The thousands and thousands he helped already have a path to citizenship the current system provide a path to be a citizen they don't need ask for.

honestly i dont give a rats ass if i become a US citizen or not... all i care about is if they gonna let me go see my family and allow me to work ....end of story

You feel like that now, but you never know what the future may bring. To be fair I don't know you, but let's say you're a hot-shot engineering major with a 3.0 GPA or better, would you honestly not want the chance to work at a job that offers security clearance? Or would you honestly not want the chance to vote and at least have an input for the future of the country. Wouldn't you? Interested in your views.

I most definitely want to become a citizen because I love this country and want to live here the rest of my life. I think that the proposal they showed at the end of January makes it really hard for people to become US citizens anyway (except dreamers and agricultural workers) so whether or not they want to be citizens is irrelevant. If they do want to be citizens they stick it out, but if they don't they'll make their money and go back, and come back make more money and leave again. So fix the system.