DREAM Act Portal Forum

DREAM Act Portal Forum (http://dreamact.info/forum/index.php)
-   The Lounge (http://dreamact.info/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   *****RFE Thread <- (Request for Evidence)**** (http://dreamact.info/forum/showthread.php?t=32596)

hooney 10-06-2012 12:13 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Laker24x (Post 331281)
Easily one of the best threads out there for future generation applicants... Props OP

Why, Thank you!
Hopefully we can get more submissions.

MadMan 10-06-2012 12:30 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Good work, it will save a lot of delays. ;-)

Phanu9000 10-06-2012 12:31 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Thank you so much for making this thread.

gcgb53191 10-06-2012 02:37 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Just did my biometrics, hoping that I don't get an RFE. I feel like I have everything pretty much covered but maybe you guys did as well so I'm pretty nervous now!

I've been here since I was 3-4 so I have records from k-12 and some college transcripts. I do have some doctor stuff from this year because I wasn't able to go to school (because of tuition) and I don't work so no proof of bank statements or anything. I didn't have much to send for proof of the 15h besides facebook post check in that I went to Flagstaff for a festival :( Wish me luck guys! Can't wait to get a sense of peace soon.

Brooklyn 10-06-2012 02:49 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Hi everyone am new to this.
Has anybody applied with a GED enrollment?

hooney 10-06-2012 12:41 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Interesting statistics I found.

http://cis.org/sites/default/files/D...09272012KB.pdf

Neksrov 10-06-2012 01:22 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
For the continuance residence proof of this year between '07, I sent in a few banks statements, college transcripts, and a printed page of my Time Warner Cable receipt. My concern is particularly focused on the few proofs, but substantial, quiet guaranteed that I had been living here, the only problem I see with this, is that I didn't--for the bank statements and Time Warner Monthly Statement-- print out single one-by-one all of the months since the year I initiated my official membership. The college transcripts were almost an assurance to me, that I had adequately provided affirmative proof of my residence to the date required. But I fear, noticing some of the results others have faced, simply with proof of only submitting the articles of: school transcripts, bank statements. Maybe, possibly, my chances to receive approval are stumped after my Biometric appointment, and I must inquire on the subject...Is it enough? Is it enough to supply only a few scattered months of worth, of official client membership, in establishing continuance U.S residency? The receipt and bank statements include my account numbers both of which are active to this day.

hooney 10-06-2012 04:23 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neksrov (Post 331626)
For the continuance residence proof of this year between '07, I sent in a few banks statements, college transcripts, and a printed page of my Time Warner Cable receipt. My concern is particularly focused on the few proofs, but substantial, quiet guaranteed that I had been living here, the only problem I see with this, is that I didn't--for the bank statements and Time Warner Monthly Statement-- print out single one-by-one all of the months since the year I initiated my official membership. The college transcripts were almost an assurance to me, that I had adequately provided affirmative proof of my residence to the date required. But I fear, noticing some of the results others have faced, simply with proof of only submitting the articles of: school transcripts, bank statements. Maybe, possibly, my chances to receive approval are stumped after my Biometric appointment, and I must inquire on the subject...Is it enough? Is it enough to supply only a few scattered months of worth, of official client membership, in establishing continuance U.S residency? The receipt and bank statements include my account numbers both of which are active to this day.

I didn't print out month-to-month for bank statements either. School records cover the most. I said this earlier but I had an year gap, for that gap I had sent in the bank statements; two bank statements.

No one here can say "enough" decisively but that's what I did.
And some of us here who got approved already did that as well.

Oasis 10-07-2012 04:16 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Case type: Visa overstay

Evidence:
Entry before 16 - My 194 visa and passport stamp
Graduated high school - My Diploma on 2005
Continuous presence 2006: Kaplan summer class registration
Continuous presence for June 2007: Money transfer paypal transaction and old passport that expired 2007 telling them i renewed it 2007 in the US.
Continuous presence for 2008-2011 college transcript
Continue presence for 2012 June 15th - bank statement for the month of June

hooney 10-07-2012 04:17 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332118)
Case type: Visa overstay

Evidence:
Entry before 16 - My 194 visa and passport stamp
Graduated high school - My Diploma on 2005
Continuous presence 2006: Kaplan summer class registration
Continuous presence for June 2007: Money transfer paypal transaction and old passport that expired 2007 telling them i renewed it 2007 in the US.
Continuous presence for 2008-2011 college transcript
Continue presence for 2012 June 15th - bank statement for the month of June

Wait, did you get an RFE? Can I get the date and the reason for RFE?

Oasis 10-07-2012 04:22 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hooney (Post 332119)
Wait, did you get an RFE? Can I get the date and the reason for RFE?

Waiting for the letter RFE date 10/2/12

hooney 10-07-2012 04:24 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332118)
Case type: Visa overstay

Evidence:
Entry before 16 - My 194 visa and passport stamp
Graduated high school - My Diploma on 2005
Continuous presence 2006: Kaplan summer class registration
Continuous presence for June 2007: Money transfer paypal transaction and old passport that expired 2007 telling them i renewed it 2007 in the US.
Continuous presence for 2008-2011 college transcript
Continue presence for 2012 June 15th - bank statement for the month of June

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332121)
Waiting for the letter RFE date 10/2/12

Alright, Thanks. Can you get back to me after you send your response? I'll add the initial info in meantime.

Oasis 10-07-2012 04:28 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hooney (Post 332122)
Alright, Thanks. Can you get back to me after you send your response? I'll add the initial info in meantime.

You got it!

SK18 10-07-2012 04:37 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Hooney you are teh great.

They should let you moderate this thread (somehow?)

Also, if somehow you guys could add 'Evidence sent originally regarding RFE:' that would be great. Alot of DACA'ers ask "wait what did you send in originally?"

hooney 10-07-2012 05:03 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SK18 (Post 332126)
Hooney you are teh great.

They should let you moderate this thread (somehow?)

Also, if somehow you guys could add 'Evidence sent originally regarding RFE:' that would be great. Alot of DACA'ers ask "wait what did you send in originally?"

Oh Thanks!

Yeah I'll add that to the format.

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 11:20 AM

Re: [add RFE 1]
 
_____________________________________________________________________________________

Username: jayman2717
9Application Delivered: 8/22/12
Service Center: Vermont
Biometric Done: 9/10/12

Original Evidence:
one medical report
school grade reports
school transcript
my uncle tax return

proof present on june 152012
june bank statement having transction on june 12
and june 21
electric bill for june

proof of c presence for five years
car registration for 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
car insurence 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
2 bank statement per year 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
my 4and half year old son birth certificate
ged certificate dated sep 2007
public library written statment saying
i been member for past seven years
i really did not send any thing for june july august 2007 . i thought i provided public library letter.

RFE Notice Date: 10/01/12. received in mail 10/03/12
RFE Reason: Asking me to prove between June 15 2007 to august 2007
RFE Response: I send in notarized letter from landlord saying i been living there for seven years including June July august 2007. Money order receipts showing that i paid rent for those three months and Hospital form dated may 2007.
RFE Sent Date: 10/04/12
RFE Delivered: TBA

Approval: TBA

_____________________________________________________________________________________[/quote]

I can't believe you got an RFE for 2 months. Who ever is. Checking your application must be harda** Good luck

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 11:24 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MadMan (Post 331401)
Good work, it will save a lot of delays. ;-)

Off-topic. Totally love your icon.

hooney 10-07-2012 05:12 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332165)
Off-topic. Totally love your icon.

Is that Johnny Depp? Looks like its from movie Public Enemy.

hooney 10-07-2012 05:15 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Lol. Nvm. It's Jon Hamm from Mad men. Totally missed the obvious hint.

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 05:18 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hooney (Post 332278)
Lol. Nvm. It's Jon Hamm from Mad men. Totally missed the obvious hint.

Lol yes its John Hamm. I love thY show. It's so good. :)

TAKEaPillChill 10-07-2012 06:23 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hooney (Post 331594)

That's hilarious. 19 born in the U.S.

karega 10-07-2012 06:56 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TAKEaPillChill (Post 332305)
That's hilarious. 19 born in the U.S.

LoL! I'm hoping that they just made a typo.

Oasis 10-07-2012 08:13 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hooney (Post 332122)
Alright, Thanks. Can you get back to me after you send your response? I'll add the initial info in meantime.

Got the mail they are asking me to prove the whole continous 5 years evidence again

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 09:09 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332352)
Got the mail they are asking me to prove the whole continous 5 years evidence again

That sucks! I'm sorry.

Reading again over your case I think your solid with your college transcripts. If you have had your bank account since at least 2007 or when ever you opened it I would include all the possible statements. How about doctor visits? If your part of a church maybe the priest can write a letter stating that you have been a member since year...

Oasis 10-07-2012 09:19 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332389)
That sucks! I'm sorry.

Reading again over your case I think your solid with your college transcripts. If you have had your bank account since at least 2007 or when ever you opened it I would include all the possible statements. How about doctor visits? If your part of a church maybe the priest can write a letter stating that you have been a member since year...

i had my first bank account 2008 not 2007 but ill see if my priest will write the letter now i have to fly down to Boston from Texas to get all these evidence i don't even live in boston anymore..

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 09:23 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332396)
i had my first bank account 2008 not 2007 but ill see if my priest will write the letter now i have to fly down to Boston from Texas to get all these evidence i don't even live in boston anymore..

I see either way your bank statements from 2008 to present will definitely work. Since when have you been living in TX?

Oasis 10-07-2012 09:37 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332397)
I see either way your bank statements from 2008 to present will definitely work. Since when have you been living in TX?

October last year

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 09:44 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332405)
October last year

Okay so maybe since then you can send utility bills under your name. Oh also well at least here when you change your address USPS sends you a notice confirming your address change so that might help.

Oasis 10-07-2012 09:51 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332409)
Okay so maybe since then you can send utility bills under your name. Oh also well at least here when you change your address USPS sends you a notice confirming your address change so that might help.

i wish that was the case... I was staying with my family and my name is not in anything and the bank i had from 2008 i closed it in 2011 so im gonna be asking for a statement from account i no longer have hopefully everything work out well.

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 09:56 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332415)
i wish that was the case... I was staying with my family and my name is not in anything and the bank i had from 2008 i closed it in 2011 so im gonna be asking for a statement from account i no longer have hopefully everything work out well.

oh poop! Maybe cellphone records. If I think of anything else that comes up since I also live with my parents I'll def post! Good luck Oasis!!

cowgirl 10-07-2012 09:59 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
I sent college transcripts from 2008 to present I was enrolled in June my lawyer even highlighted that now im worried that they will send me an RFE :/

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 10:06 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cowgirl (Post 332420)
I sent college transcripts from 2008 to present I was enrolled in June my lawyer even highlighted that now im worried that they will send me an RFE :/

hi cowgirl!! Don't worry yet! Gotta wait and see what happens. It doesn't only depend on your college transcripts also on the other evidence you sent. Others factors also include your Service Center, your case officer, and even where you live(mail). Don't worry yet. Take it step by step!

btw what's your timeline? What other evidence did you submit?

cowgirl 10-07-2012 10:17 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332421)
hi cowgirl!! Don't worry yet! Gotta wait and see what happens. It doesn't only depend on your college transcripts also on the other evidence you sent. Others factors also include your Service Center, your case officer, and even where you live(mail). Don't worry yet. Take it step by step!

btw what's your timeline? What other evidence did you submit?


I don't know how to do the time line but I got receipt letters on September 27 got appointment October 30 I sent school diploma, school id cards , passport ,college transcript high school transcript,vaccination records and I think that's all my service center is Nebraska I live in Texas

Stephanie61593 10-07-2012 10:22 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cowgirl (Post 332426)
I don't know how to do the time line but I got receipt letters on September 27 got appointment October 30 I sent school diploma, school id cards , passport ,college transcript high school transcript,vaccination records and I think that's all my service center is Nebraska I live in Texas

that seems like a good package. Especially since most is school things its very valuable.

You can do your timeline by going to "Control Panel on the left side" and then go to "Settings drop down menu and it says 'edit signature'" :)

cyan 10-07-2012 10:24 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
I am actually curious. For those who were visa overstays and received an rfe, where were they from originally?

cowgirl 10-07-2012 10:24 PM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332421)
hi cowgirl!! Don't worry yet! Gotta wait and see what happens. It doesn't only depend on your college transcripts also on the other evidence you sent. Others factors also include your Service Center, your case officer, and even where you live(mail). Don't worry yet. Take it step by step!

btw what's your timeline? What other evidence did you submit?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephanie61593 (Post 332428)
that seems like a good package. Especially since most is school things its very valuable.

You can do your timeline by going to "Control Panel on the left side" and then go to "Settings drop down menu and it says 'edit signature'" :)

Yes I have no other proof except that I'm confident thanks I will do that right now

Dreamer_Hind 10-08-2012 01:26 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Please Help me!

Username: Dreamer_Hind
EWI: NO/ Visa Overstay
Application Delivered: (08/21/12)
I-1145 Received: (08/24/12)
Service Center: (Vermont)
Biometric Done: (09/12/12)

Original Evidence: Expired(2006) Passport with last entry date in 2000 when I first came here. I-94 which has no stamp on the back so I thought that would be sufficient for residency since I never left US. Birth certificate. High school report cards from 2006 till 2010 with High School Diploma and original transcript(graduated on June 14, 2010.) A receipt for a cell phone case I bought on June 15, 2012.

RFE Notice Date: (09/27/12)
RFE Reason: You submitted your high school transcripts which establish your residence until your graduation on June 14, 2010. You also submitted a receipt from cell phone accessories dated June 15, 2012, but the document is not enough to show residency for two year period between the date you graduated and the date on the receipt. Therefore, additional evidence is needed to show you continuously resided in US since you graduated from high school.

RFE Response:

RFE Sent Date: (Your response date 12/23/12)
RFE Delivered:

Follow-up/Comment: I do not know what I can send because I have nothing under my name. I don't work anywhere and I have one picture I took with my friends in October 2011 and I attended a wedding on May 2012. I came here with visitor's visa and overstayed. After I graduated I never left any foot print behind nor I hung out with friends. I do have 3 receipts that I took a picture of but don't have the actual receipt because the iphone app "Lemon" saves the receipts but the receipts are from local store and Walmart which doesn't have my name on them and are dated on November 2011. I live under someone's name and I have nothing under my name. I am thinking to send affidavit of my friends saying we met a lot of times in the form of this:
I, the undersigned, NAME OF PERSON WRITING AFFIDAVIT, do hereby solemnly affirm and declare on oath that:

1. I have been personally acquainted with [BENEFICIARY] since [DATE].

2. I am personally acquainted with [BENEFICIARY} as [DESCRIBE THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BENEFICIARY AND PERSON WRITING AFFIDAVIT]

3. During the period starting [BEGINNING DATE OF TIME GAP] and ending [END DATE OF TIME GAP], I personally witnessed {BENEFICIARY] residing and being present in the United States on the following occasions:

a. [OCCASION #1—include specific information about dates, locations, and activities]
b. [OCCASION #2--ditto]
c. [Etc.]
--------------------------------------------------------------------

But I know this isn't strong evidence to proof continuous residency.

Approval: (TBA/Approved Date/Denied Date)

iDream 10-08-2012 02:15 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
why the fuck are they RFE'ing people for the smallest fucken reason?

hooney 10-08-2012 08:27 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 332352)
Got the mail they are asking me to prove the whole continous 5 years evidence again

Wait, so you just got the RFE mail?

I already had the RFE reason from you for:
Submit evidence which clearly establishes con't presence from 2011 to before June 15, 2012.

car0593 10-08-2012 08:32 AM

Re: >>>>>>>>>RFE Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iDream (Post 332544)
why the fuck are they RFE'ing people for the smallest fucken reason?

Maybe they are trying to backlog the system even more just in case Romney gets elected & not that many people get approved ? This is just a speculation, who knows?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:37 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.