DREAM Act Portal Forum - Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

DREAM Act Portal Forum (http://dreamact.info/forum/index.php)

- The News Room (http://dreamact.info/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=23)

- - Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election? (http://dreamact.info/forum/showthread.php?t=26961)

Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

Quote:

The GOP is launching its secret weapon.

The one with an ethnic persona and an assumed comfort level with a coveted demographic, along with boyish good looks and tea party credentials for added charm.

Good luck, Florida Sen. Marco Rubio. You will need it.

Talk is turning to November, to Mitt Romney's future. It's the math, the math.

Sorry, Newt and Rick, but he's the nominee. And already the talk is turning to who will be his copilot. Those conversations always include Marco Rubio as a possibility, although Rubio himself is quick to demur to any such suggestion.

In nearly the same breath that Rubio endorsed Romney for the nomination, the Cuban-American senator confirmed that he is drafting a GOP-friendly version of the long exiled DREAM Act.

Ay, caramba! Who do you think Republicans are trying to court with that maneuver?

The 21 million Latinos eligible to vote?

DREAM stands for Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors. The federal DREAM Act has had several iterations over the years, and there have been state bills as well. The main objective has been to allow immigrant children, most of whom have grown up in the United States believing themselves to be American, the opportunity to go to college or enter the military as a means to legal status.

No word yet on exactly what Rubio's version would propose. He has discussed a version of the DREAM Act that would allow legalization, but not a path to citizenship.

That's a recipe for permanent limbo for these immigrant kids. And it's not likely to fly with Democrats. According to The Hill, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid spoke to Hispanic business leaders recently, warning them not to be fooled by shallow outreach efforts by Republicans, specifically mentioning the possibility of a weakened DREAM Act.

"While you're here in town, don't take the bait that will be given to you by my Republican friends," Reid reportedly said.

Used to be, back before the GOP threw common sense to the wind and adopted a harsh view on anything tinged by immigration, many Republicans backed the DREAM Act. They realized that these children didn't uproot themselves from native lands and enter the U.S. without legal paperwork. Their parents made those choices. Why punish the children when they are eager to be college-educated, tax-paying additions to the U.S. economy?

That's no longer a rhetorical question. The answer is: because the tea party says you should.

So Rubio, in his first task to prove what he can do for the GOP, is going to set this ship upright? Good luck, senator. You will need it.

There's not a lot of reason to trust Rubio on this issue. He denounced an earlier version of the federal DREAM Act as an "amnesty." Changing his tune now will look like flip-flopping. And that might just entrench Latino voters' mistrust of the GOP.

Romney's camp might see Rubio as a natural ally to Latino voters. Maybe someone should tell them.

Rubio is Cuban-American, the son of exiles (although his parents arrived two years before Castro took power). Many Cubans have a completely different relationship with immigration issues than other Hispanics in the U.S. When you flee a dictator that the U.S. government considers a foe, legal status can be obtained as a refugee.

The vast majority of Hispanics who come to the U.S. are of Mexican or Central American origin. That's not a deal they get from our government.

Another twist is that Latino voters don't rank immigration policy among the most important issues. They are concerned mostly about employment, education, jobs -- the range of issues that most voters find important.

Still, if Rubio gets behind a strong and equitable version of the DREAM Act, he can help a small but important number of immigrants whose status should have been resolved long ago. These students' futures never should have been become a political football.

Maybe Rubio can be the voice that brings reason to the GOP.

Good luck, Sen. Rubio. You will need it.

http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/201...erican-senator

Re: Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

he's a fucking tool alright....

Re: Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

He might be a hero more than a tool. Right now, i have more hopes for him than the Democrats.

Re: Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

more like a sTOOL. -_-

Re: Tool or hero — what role will Marco Rubio play in 2012 election?

Quote:

Originally Posted by ECL23 (Post 250047)

more like a sTOOL. -_-

hahaha I like that.

Let me be our voice of reason. Self-appointed voice of reason isn't always a good idea, but I'm not controlled by politics nor do I have to appease anyone with my word choice. I don't think we should be judging Rubio. He really can't by himself help us like we want to be helped. And his allies haven't been know to make life easier for us either. So if you're expecting a solution that saves us, you will be disappointed. It will be a solution though I guarantee you that, but do not be fooled by your desperate notions that all will be well with a visa. It won't be, not by a long shot. This alternative can only be a plot to make it harder for us in the future, and if it passes ahead of the original we can kiss any future salvation goodbye. Why? You might ask. Well after they gave us one solution do you really think they're gonna give us another? If so, you're bigger dreamers than I ever imagined. And if you think getting married will put you on the fast track to citizenship, first figure out how that process works, and then imagine almost all of us attempting it. The reason a visa won't help us is because the immigration system is broken. If we let them toss us into that system surely most of us will be in jeopardy once again. We can't settle for that. And the cherry to top it off... Rubio admits that the immigration system is broken. Why do you think he wants it to handle us? Two birds with one stone I suppose. But that is just a conspiracy theory I came up with. In reality the bill may help us, but from the looks of it we will be hung out to dry. But it should serve as a back up plan.

We are all looking for a hero, but I have never heard of a political hero so don't hold your breath. First of all Rubio was against the original DREAM act. Who do you think he is trying to appease? Definitely not us. They have under the table motives, and so do the democrats, but at least the democrats our for the original DREAM act. Which is a bi partisan bill. People have to be reminded of that. So stay positive and hopeful for the DREAM act. I know it may seem pessimistic of me to rant on about the negative sides to Rubio's proposal, but I can't let you guys draw to conclusions before the bill is even out. I am still open-minded. I suggest you open yours to all of the possibilities and think about the big picture. A solution for today is not a solution for tomorrow. Hopefully this last little phrase will put that into perspective... "Give a man a fish, and he'll eat for a day. Teach a man to fish and he'll eat for a lifetime."

Ask yourself "Do you want to be legal for 4 years, 4 more years in some of the more fortunate cases, or do you want a chance to be a U.S. citizen?" I know my answer.