Julian Castro vs. Marco Rubio

http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/DC-Deco...co-Rubio-video



Who is Julian Castro? He’s the mayor of San Antonio, Texas, and tonight’s keynote speaker at the Democratic National Convention, that’s who.

Peter Grier
Washington Editor

Peter Grier is The Christian Science Monitor's Washington editor. In this capacity, he helps direct coverage for the paper on most news events in the nation's capital.


In Pictures: The Democratic National Convention 2012


Is Julian Castro the Democrats' Marco Rubio? (+video)
09.04.12



He’ll be the first Hispanic to ever deliver the DNC keynote. Democrats think he’s popular enough to rise to Lone Star State governor, or even higher office. He’s got a compelling personal story – he was raised by a strong single mom who was herself politically active. He’s got an identical twin brother who represents San Antonio in the state legislature and is likely to be elected to Congress in November.

He’s young, only 37, and has risen fast. Sound like anyone else? Yes, that’s what we thought too – he’s the Democrats' answer to Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida. Except Senator Rubio’s not an identical twin.

How much do you know about political convention history? Take our quiz.

Rubio did well for himself in Tampa, Fla., with a speech that some political analysts think may have set him apart from New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, vice presidential nominee Paul Ryan, and other non-Romney party heavyweights. Mr. Castro’s not at Rubio’s level yet in the sense that nobody’s talking about him as a potential 2016 nominee. But in giving the San Antonio mayor the keynote speech, Democrats may be trying to broaden their bench of nationally known figures, while attempting to woo the Hispanic vote. A twofer.

Castro's father and mother split up when he was eight. He and twin sibling Joaquin were raised by their mom, Maria “Rosie” Castro, who was an organizer in the Texas Mexican-American community in the 1970s. Her activities drew hate mail and even the interest of the Justice Department.

But today Castro says it was his mom and others like her who broke barriers, allowing Hispanics like him to have a political future.

“It was very warranted at that time,” he told the Associated Press. “You had a huge dropout rate. You had signs that said, ‘No Mexicans or dogs allowed.’ It was a movement born out of both aspiration and frustration, it was very understandable. And ultimately, I believe, [it] helped move this country forward.”

His mom emphasized grades as well, paying for high marks. That paid off – Castro went to Stanford and Harvard Law. He’s the youngest person ever elected to the San Antonio City Council, where he won a seat in 2001. He lost a try for the mayor’s seat in 2005, then came back to win on his second try, in 2009. He was reelected in 2011.

He’s a nonpartisan office holder in a city manager form of government, notes the Dallas Morning News today in a good piece on his background. Castro “brings a life of contrasts” into his keynote address, writes the Dallas paper’s Robert T. Garrett. He’s a shy politician, a red state Democrat, and so on.

“Castro is hyped as a future statewide or even national candidate despite his short resume. The mayor, though, has dug in to solve problems at the local level for most of a decade – and plans to stay there for a while,” writes Mr. Garrett.

Republicans, though, say that they’ve seen this movie before – in 2004, when the young and unknown Barack Obama got the chance to boost his national profile by delivering a DNC keynote.

Conservatives criticize the choice of Castro by saying he’s done little to actually merit an appearance hundreds of more experienced politicians would love to make.

“It is kind of creepy to see just how many hurrahs and hosannas a politician [can] generate without actually doing much of anything, particularly on bread-and-butter issues like crime and education. If a Castro defender wants to argue he’s only been in office three years, fine ... but that just raises the question of why an unaccomplished mayor is giving the keynote address. It’s like watching the Obama playbook from 2004 all over again,” writes the National Review’s Jim Geraghty in his The Campaign Spot blog.

the Mexican vs the Cuban

Not even fair, Mr. Castro gave a phenomenal speech with substance and facts behind it.

I go for the Mexican. I am Made In Mexico.

Castro just ate a fiesta and took a shit on Marco Rubio's chest with that speech and delivery.

I liked his speech, didn't know him at all here in Houston 'cause we have our own cool mayor- Anise Parker

There's one difference. Castro has substance while Rubio is a clown.

I was teary eyed brahs... I can relate to this guy.
I came to the job I hate today with a renewed sense of pride and a new inspiration to look up to.

Yea the democrats gave such good speeches compare the the republicans. The republicans all they did was criticize Obama and did not mention anything from their platform besides saying that he was going to create jobs over and over again. i think Micheal Obama and Julian Castro had way better speech than Romney

I am a liberal Democrat on so many aspects.

But I will NOT support another inexperienced candidate in the future, as much as the Democratic Party wants to push it as their new "Obama" just because he is young, latino, and eloquent.

We need experienced elected officials with a RECORD of getting things DONE.

I hope the Dems don't fall for another Obama like Castro. He has ZERO credentials as to why he should be the next President.

Rubio is the same way. Just stop falling for the 24/7 news cycle show! Think about what candidates, and candidates to be, have to offer and have done, NOT what CNN, FOX NEWS or MSNBC is deciding or have decided for you to believe.