Deportation Decision Close For 'DREAM 9' Immigrant Activists - Page 2

they can travel inside of mexico now.

Even though I think we should all stand behind these activists and give them support, I have to admit that it's a really really bad move.

Fuck yeah, i'll be pretty pissed as well, that's bullshit. Its like that guy i know who got a DUI and they gave him a fucking work permit. What kind of shit?


These guys shouldn't be rewarded for bringing this to "light" we all know the immigration system is broken, and if these guys get legalization through this way, it wouldn't be fair to the millions who have gotten denied asylum based on the same criteria that these guys are bringing up.

They shouldn't have left. Its like.. they couldn't handle it before, so now that they saw an opportunity they want to come back because they swear they deserve to be here. YOU MADE A CHOICE TO GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY. They deserve nothing from here. I bet you they thought things were going to be better for them over in Mexico, which is why they left in the first place, so the asylum case based on fear should be thrown out just based on that. If they do get let go, we should all go back and get status that way. bullshit is what this is.

I honestly think this is hurting the CIR push. Why in the world did they do this?

What good reasons do they have to apply for asylum? They are all coming from Mexico...sure it's very violent over there but I've heard that many Mexicans have tried to petition for TPS for Mexicans because of the violence and obviously that's not going to happen.

I think they just went YOLO on us. Besides, they would not qualify for DACA because they were either not present here in the US and/or left before they were even approved for it.

I'm very sure that it must be horrible to be deported but they really should've been a little patient. Wasn't CIR going to include a section for those that had been deported?

Also, supporters of the D.A. have always mentioned how we were brought to the U.S. with no proper documentation through no fault of our own. How are they holding up to that when they as adults decided to leave and now return with no papers. I am just in shock.

I truly wish the best for them and I wish they were allowed back in but let's be realistic if that does happen that will really hurt CIR.

A cir would sort of help those who left prior to a specific date. But these people would not qualify in the Senate's version. And it's what I have been saying. The whole Dream Act basis has been revolving on the idea that it's meant to help those who were brought here throught no fault of their own. It's literally it's only advantage. Why would people brought here taken from their homes and families be punish for something their parents did. It make sense to do something about that. Notice how the media focuses more on this point that any other. Them going back to protests completly destroyed that argument. If they exempted and given asylum, the whole thing about the USA having a broke immigrt system needs fixing would be damage. Anti cir groups would start using this. "We don't need a reform if you're here illegal just back to your country and ask for asylum" lots of way to protests but self deportation it's not the greatest. Nor effective. I wonder how the person who advise them feels. "oh well I'm least I'm still in the USA not like them "

After a long and very productive work week, during which we were short-staffed and I performed the work of two people, triaged dozens of phone calls from high-risk patients and helped patients in need of urgent care, where hundreds of dollars in taxes are withheld from my payroll, it amuses me to look here and see the tunnel-vision and incompassionate posts of the inexperienced and immature who believe that their own lives are models of conduct for others. Ha!

These guys are inadmissible but not deportable because they qualify for DACA - now their lawyers will have to find a way around this argument. These people are on U.S. soil now and I highly doubt it that they are going to be expelled, so get over it. And no, if they get permission to stay it won't hurt any one of you or me or the CIR legislation; they will get a work permit and authorization to live here while their cases make it throught the court system. If you're a DACA recipient, you already have your work permit and authorization to live here, and not one of you are the 'decider' of these individuals' fates, nor are any of us legally trained to assert what should be done with them.

They qualified for DACA while they were still here. They left the country. Not sure how DACA would help them now.

Not one of you are the 'decider' of these individuals' fates, nor are any of us legally trained to assert what should be done with them.

Because our opinions are REALLY going to make a difference

You are one seriously butthurt poster. Oh well, like I said, best of luck to these people who decided to throw it all away

Daca? what? these people don't even qualify for the senate CIR bill.

I support their request to return and stay in the country they call home. Even DACA allowed for previous departure and return, and many here have confessed to doing so; these people were desperate and have come forward to completely tell their stories and struggles and their only way out was to challenge the system and test themselves.

Many here are passing judgement on them, not on the basis of breaking the law, but judging of their 'choice to throw it all way'. Who made you the moral police? Who are we to say that they should be deported and to wish them failure in their bid to stay in the U.S.?

Actually, I know exactly who is going to rant against them, they are the ones who seem to think that every reply post is about them and they are too dim to see that they are taking the bait.

right, but just not the way they did it. Also, since you don't qualify for DACA what's to stop you from doing what they did, they basically forfeited DACA and are now asking of asylum based on humanitarian purposes, that's what they HAD to do. Why don't you go back and get taken in too, i'm sure if these guys get EAD's you'll get it too because shit, you qualified for DACA at one point.

This whole thing is about US, DREAMERS not just DREAM9 .. . they even got their own name.

Good luck.