What would an amnesty do to America?

IF we get amnesty or any form of legalization, is this good or bad for America? I think it's great because there are more tax payers and more people to work. I don't see how amnesty can be bad though if it was given to hard working folks (criminals get deported). Why would this be a bad thing? Ali-retards are so against it but I really do think it's great for the economy. Even the secretary of commerce says it's a good thing.

You know how there is billions of dollars being pumped into the Social Security by undocumented workers that will never be taken off because they/we cant benefit due to status.. America would lose that and all the baby boomers would be in bigger trouble.

What amnesty are you talking about? I haven't heard of any amnesty since 1986.

I'm not talking about a particular type, I'm only saying what would an amnesty do to America.

Yea I remember how my under the table checks used to be cut by these federal social security taxes that I will never see in this lifetime

I think the estimate is $2billion per year from undocumented workers? Anyway, sounds like a gross underestimation.

Valentine... why are all your threads so negative?

Listen woman, if you ever want DREAM or CIR to pass you want to stay farrrrrrrrrrr away from the word amnesty don't even use the word amnesty, 99% of the citizen DON"T WANT amnesty, because it failed before DO YOU REMEMBER ? please people let's try not to argue about how amnesty is good, or how immigrants contributed more than the citizen have, I'm begging you people please stop using those word and arguments. I just can't believe this, god damn it.

they're negative? how so? i dont see this as a negative thing, just wondering what's gonna happen 'tis all. it's a positive thing for all of us! just wondering what's the outcome of it

no no, let's say we have another reagen like in the old times!

my point is: what are the outcomes of this? cuz our opposition is always against it, and they probably dont know that it benefits them in the long run. i see it as a good thing for the economy but alipacers dont. i didnt say amnesty was good... when did i say that.. i didnt think cir was amnesty at all because all of all the terms we had to go through. dream is certainly not amnesty if we have to go to college or join up. -_-

China for example, is having what's called birth control, because there are too many people to feed, now if you can't feed that many people most likely poor people, the consequence would be they can't afford to go to college, can't get no jobs, and will become the lower class of the society sooner than later, certainly American don't want that.

Now, America is the only country that against high intelligent, this society don't appreciate scientists, engineers, but sports, guns violence. that's why they have to grab brain power from all over the world, go visit NASA 15% of their best scientists are Chinese 12% Indians. this is why that I want the New Dream to have Master Degree in it, that will show that we are the people that America has been looking for from overseas.